Government has a responsibility to study both possible CRL alignments

Media Replies
22 Feb 2016

We thank all writers who have shared their views on the two possible alignments of the Cross Island Line (CRL).

The Government is studying both the underground alignments and no decision has been taken yet.  For the 4km direct alignment, 2km of the tunnel will be below the Central Catchment Nature Reserve (CCNR) while the other 2km is located outside it. The section of the tunnel beneath the CCNR will be about 40m deep, depending on findings from ground investigations. There will not be any construction of infrastructure on the surface.  The skirting alignment, about 9km long, will require longer tunnels and extra ventilation facilities. Besides land and home acquisitions that could affect families, the extra works could incur $2 billion more in expenditure.

The two alignments may have different impacts on various stakeholders - the nature reserve, businesses, home owners, commuters and taxpayers.  The Government has a responsibility to study both thoroughly before making a decision.  Ground investigations and engineering feasibility studies of both alignments have to be completed first. 

For the upcoming ground investigations, following our extensive consultations with the nature groups for the first phase of the Environmental Impact Assessment (EIA), we are reducing the number of 10cm-boreholes from 72 to 16, and confining them to public trails and existing clearings. LTA will complement these with non-intrusive geophysical survey methods and horizontal directional coring that will start from outside the CCNR.  As such, no vegetation will be cleared. NParks staff will accompany the contractors and consultants during all off-trail works to ensure that the greatest care is taken to protect the CCNR.

In making the decision on the alignment, the Government will have to consider the full range of factors including the engineering feasibility of both alignments, distance and travel time for commuters, cost to taxpayers, and the impact on the CCNR and on businesses and families who may be affected by land acquisition under the skirting option. Indeed, since the gazette of the EIA, homeowners had asked to meet LTA and voiced their concerns over possible acquisition of their homes.  They urged the Government to be objective, and take into account also their concerns. 

In response to requests from the public, the findings of Phase 1 of the EIA have been made available on the LTA website from 19 Feb.    

We thank the public for sharing their views and will take into account the diverse concerns of different stakeholders.

Chew Men Leong
Chief Executive
Land Transport Authority